Skip to main content
Site Logo
  • My Listings
  • Featured Areas
  • Resources
    • Local Resources
  • Buy
    • Perfect Home Finder
    • Buyers
    • Helpful Guides
    • Mortgage Calculator
    • Affordability Calculator
  • Sell
    • Home Valuation
    • Sellers
    • Connecticut Seller Seminar
    • Helpful Guides
  • About
    • Meet my Team
    • Ashley Pushee
    • Success Stories
    • Blog
  • Contact Me
 
Menu
  • My Listings
  • Featured Areas
  • Resources
  • Buy
  • Sell
  • About
  • Contact Me
Resources
  • Local Resources
Buy
  • Perfect Home Finder
  • Buyers
  • Helpful Guides
  • Mortgage Calculator
  • Affordability Calculator
Sell
  • Home Valuation
  • Sellers
  • Connecticut Seller Seminar
  • Helpful Guides
About
  • Meet my Team
  • Ashley Pushee
  • Success Stories
  • Blog
  • Home
  • About Me
  • Success Stories
  • Blog
  • Contact
Real Estate
  • Buyers
  • Sellers
  • Featured Areas
  • Helpful Guides
Tools
  • Perfect Home Finder
  • Home Valuation
  • Mortgage Calculator
Dashboard
Listings
Searches
Sign in / Sign up
Price
Beds
Baths
More
Save Search
Old Lyme, CT
City
Reset
Share
1 - 44 of 44 listings (44 total matches)
Newest Listings
Hide Map
314 Ferry Road Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 2 weeks on site
1 / 40
$4,250,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
4,505
SQFT
314 Ferry Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Karen Amlong Lee of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (203) 245-4700 Broker Contact: (860) 575-6574
1 & 3 Neck Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$2,650,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
6,742
SQFT
1 & 3 Neck Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Jennifer Caulfield of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 388-7710
5 Old Stagecoach and Boston Post Road Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 2 weeks on site
1 / 17
$2,300,000
Land For Sale
Active
135.3
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
5 Old Stagecoach and Boston Post Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Heather Clinton of Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop. Office Phone: (203) 245-3100 Broker Contact: (203) 530-7363
1 Seaside Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 2 weeks on site
1 / 36
$1,699,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,782
SQFT
1 Seaside Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Angela Aresco of Carl Guild & Associates Office Phone: (860) 474-3500 Broker Contact: [email protected]
9 Matson Ridge Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 3 days on site
1 / 40
$1,550,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,478
SQFT
9 Matson Ridge
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Matson Ridge Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Teri Lewis of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 227-7913
8 Lieutenant River Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 37
$1,500,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,215
SQFT
8 Lieutenant River Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Old Lyme Historic Village Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 434-2400 Broker Contact: (860) 867-6120
2 Berberis Drive Old Lyme CT 06371
Open House Sun, Apr 12, 1 PM
Please verify times due to COVID-19
1 / 40
$1,400,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
3,682
SQFT
2 Berberis Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Peppermint Ridge Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Nancy Mesham of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 227-9071
14 Cutler Road Old Lyme CT 06371
Open House Sun, Apr 12, 12 PM
Please verify times due to COVID-19
1 / 34
$1,399,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
2,722
SQFT
14 Cutler Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Colette Harron of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 304-2391
23 Lords Meadow Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$1,300,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
4
BEDS
6
TOTAL BATHS
3,293
SQFT
23 Lords Meadow Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Lords Meadow Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 434-2400 Broker Contact: (860) 867-6120
3-A Meetinghouse Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 2 weeks on site
1 / 25
$1,250,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
3,971
SQFT
3-A Meetinghouse Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Colette Harron of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 304-2391
11 Buttonball Road "The Ashton" Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 40
$1,250,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,192
SQFT
11 Buttonball Road "The Ashton"
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Stonegate Estates Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Betsy Anderson of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (203) 245-6700 Broker Contact: (203) 641-3233
12 Matson Ridge Old Lyme CT 06371
Open House Sun, Apr 12, 12:30 PM
Please verify times due to COVID-19
1 / 40
$1,200,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
5
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
4,429
SQFT
12 Matson Ridge
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 434-2400 Broker Contact: (860) 867-6120
34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road Old Lyme CT 06371
Open House Sun, Apr 12, 12 PM
Please verify times due to COVID-19
1 / 40
$1,199,900
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
5
TOTAL BATHS
3,435
SQFT
34-1 Johnny Cake Hill Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of John Roberto of CENTURY 21 Shutters & Sails Office Phone: (860) 331-1510 Broker Contact: (860) 514-0500
60 Lyme Street Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - a week on site
1 / 40
$1,199,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,113
SQFT
60 Lyme Street
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 434-2400 Broker Contact: (860) 867-6120
56 Columbus Avenue Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - a week on site
1 / 40
$1,150,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,088
SQFT
56 Columbus Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Kevin Geysen of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 805-0000
184 Shore Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 7
$995,000
Land For Sale
Active Under Contract
25.99
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
184 Shore Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Gigi Giordano of Compass Connecticut, LLC Office Phone: (860) 767-5390 Broker Contact: (203) 671-2155
4 White Farm Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 7 days on site
1 / 19
$985,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,063
SQFT
4 White Farm Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Martha Quaratella of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 227-7611
1 Haywagon Drive Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 4 weeks on site
1 / 40
$985,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
4
BEDS
4
TOTAL BATHS
3,786
SQFT
1 Haywagon Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Beach Farms Subdivision
Listing courtesy of Terry Kemper of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 908-7820
15 Short Hills Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 31
$899,000
Land For Sale
Active Under Contract
32
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
15 Short Hills Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Curtiss Clemens Jr. of Century 21 Clemens Group Office Phone: (860) 563-0021 Broker Contact: (860) 306-7236
59 Saltaire Drive Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 40
$850,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
4
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,459
SQFT
59 Saltaire Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Madelyn Pope of RE/MAX One Office Phone: (860) 444-7362 Broker Contact: (860) 857-0850
1 Huntley Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 8
$795,000
Commercial Sale For Sale
Active
6.2
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
1 Huntley Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Gino Penasa of Seaport Real Estate Services Office Phone: (860) 245-9200 Broker Contact: (860) 984-5101
1 Huntley Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 8
$795,000
Unimproved Land For Sale
Active
6.2
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
1 Huntley Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Gino Penasa of Seaport Real Estate Services Office Phone: (860) 245-9200 Broker Contact: (860) 984-5101
44 Hartford Avenue Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 40
$750,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,608
SQFT
44 Hartford Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Adam Clemens of Century 21 Clemens Group Office Phone: (860) 563-0021 Broker Contact: (860) 989-0773
11 Jericho Drive Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 31
$745,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
1,776
SQFT
11 Jericho Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Nancy Mesham of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 227-9071
24 Saunders Hollow Road Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 4 weeks on site
1 / 37
$745,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active Under Contract
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,021
SQFT
24 Saunders Hollow Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Nancy Mesham of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 227-9071
243 Mile Creek Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 40
$725,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Pending
4
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,391
SQFT
243 Mile Creek Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Vivian Senft of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 227-9133
42 Old Colony Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$575,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Coming Soon
2
BEDS
1
TOTAL BATH
688
SQFT
42 Old Colony Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Erik Sousa of William Raveis Real Estate Office Phone: (860) 521-4311 Broker Contact: (860) 983-0457
6-1 and 8-1 Meetinghouse Lane Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 1
$550,000
Land For Sale
Active Under Contract
4.79
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
6-1 and 8-1 Meetinghouse Lane
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Jennifer Caulfield of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 388-7710
8 Biscayne Boulevard Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 36
$549,900
Single Family Residence For Sale
Coming Soon
2
BEDS
1
TOTAL BATH
872
SQFT
8 Biscayne Boulevard
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Kevin Geysen of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 805-0000
21 Four Mile River Road Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - 3 weeks on site
1 / 40
$549,900
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active Under Contract
3
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
1,743
SQFT
21 Four Mile River Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Susan Malan of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 767-7488 Broker Contact: (860) 767-5011
12 Littlefield Drive Old Lyme CT 06371
Price Change - 3 weeks ago
1 / 34
$499,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
3
BEDS
1
TOTAL BATH
1,124
SQFT
12 Littlefield Drive
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Lauren Iraeta of KW Legacy Partners Office Phone: (860) 313-0700 Broker Contact: (860) 313-0700
10 Portland Avenue Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 25
$495,000
Single Family Residence For Sale
Active
1
BED
1
TOTAL BATH
656
SQFT
10 Portland Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Kelly Anderson of William Raveis Real Estate Office Phone: (860) 388-3936 Broker Contact: (860) 964-0442
30 Hartford Avenue B Old Lyme CT 06371
New Listing - a week on site
1 / 28
$330,000
Condominium For Sale
Active
2
BEDS
1
TOTAL BATH
714
SQFT
Hartford Avenue Condominiums (30)
30 Hartford Avenue B
Old Lyme, CT 06371
Listing courtesy of Nancy Gunderman of William Raveis Real Estate Office Phone: (860) 739-4455 Broker Contact: (860) 235-6906
287 Boston Post Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 17
$250,000
Land For Sale
Active
3.83
ACRES
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
287 Boston Post Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Eric Engdall of Coldwell Banker Realty Office Phone: (860) 434-8600 Broker Contact: (860) 705-6918
54 Halls Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 6
$50,000
Business For Sale
Active
NEW LONDON
COUNTY
54 Halls Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Penny Parker of Lyman Real Estate Office Phone: (860) 887-5000 Broker Contact: (860) 575-1855
47 Brighton Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$5,500
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
4
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,766
SQFT
47 Brighton Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Ian Mackie of Berkshire Hathaway NE Prop. Office Phone: (203) 272-2828 Broker Contact: (203) 525-3858
27 Brightwater Road Old Lyme CT 06371
Price Change - 2 weeks ago
1 / 34
$5,000
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
4
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
2,247
SQFT
27 Brightwater Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Aulay Carlson of Shore & Country Real Estate Office Phone: (860) 434-1695 Broker Contact: (401) 207-2146
48 Swan Avenue Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$5,000
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
5
BEDS
3
TOTAL BATHS
3,328
SQFT
48 Swan Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Jorge Zea of Blue Lighthouse Realty, Inc Office Phone: (855) 550-0528 Broker Contact: [email protected]
55 Swan Avenue Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 40
$2,950
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
4
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
2,000
SQFT
55 Swan Avenue
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Jorge Zea of Blue Lighthouse Realty, Inc Office Phone: (855) 550-0528 Broker Contact: [email protected]
40 Portland Avenue 1 Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 39
$2,500
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
4
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
1,505
SQFT
40 Portland Avenue 1
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Del Ford of United Realty Plus Office Phone: (860) 880-0333 Broker Contact: (860) 705-3323
9 Lyme Street 7 Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 23
$2,200
Residential Lease For Rent
Pending
2
BEDS
2
TOTAL BATHS
645
SQFT
9 Lyme Street 7
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Tammy Tinnerello of William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l Office Phone: (860) 434-2400 Broker Contact: (860) 867-6120
48 Swan Avenue A Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 22
$1,800
Single Family Residence For Rent
Active
1
TOTAL BATH
3,328
SQFT
48 Swan Avenue A
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Jorge Zea of Blue Lighthouse Realty, Inc Office Phone: (855) 550-0528 Broker Contact: [email protected]
57 Hatchetts Hill Road Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 7
$15
Commercial Lease For Rent
Active
4,000
SQFT
57 Hatchetts Hill Road
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Constance Howard of U.S. Properties Real Estate Services, LLC Office Phone: (860) 691-2011 Broker Contact: (615) 293-3878
57 Hatchetts Hill Road 1 A Old Lyme CT 06371
1 / 27
$13.43
Commercial Lease For Rent
Active
8,299
SQFT
57 Hatchetts Hill Road 1 A
Old Lyme, CT 06371
 
Listing courtesy of Andrew O'Reilly of Seaport Real Estate Services Office Phone: (860) 245-9200 Broker Contact: (860) 608-5065
1 - 44 of 44 listings (44 total matches)


The data relating to real estate for sale on this website appears in part through the SMARTMLS Internet Data Exchange program, a voluntary cooperative exchange of property listing data between licensed real estate brokerage firms, and is provided by SMARTMLS through a licensing agreement. Listing information is from various brokers who participate in the SMARTMLS IDX program and not all listings may be visible on the site. The property information being provided on or through the website is for the personal, non-commercial use of consumers and such information may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some properties which appear for sale on the website may no longer be available because they are for instance, under contract, sold or are no longer being offered for sale. Property information displayed is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Copyright 2026 SmartMLS, Inc.
Last checked: 2026-04-11 10:26 PM UTC.


Share My QR
Success!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

By signing up you will receive our quarterly newsletter on variety of real-estate topics.

We respect your privacy. We will never share your email address. You can unsubscribe at any time.

BROOKE-TEAM-horizontal-white

Phone: 1-860-573-4349

Email: [email protected]

About

  • Home
  • About Me
  • Success Stories
  • Blog
  • Contact

Let's Work

  • Buyers
  • Sellers
  • Featured Areas
  • Helpful Guides

Services

  • Perfect Home Finder
  • Home Valuation
  • Mortgage Calculator

​​1266 E. Main Street, Ste 700R, Stamford, CT 06902

  • Privacy Policy

Made with by AgentFire

© 2024 Ashley Pushee